I give money to people on the street who ask for it, and recently a friend admonished me not to, that I would serve them better by giving to charities. “The ones who really need it don’t beg,” he said.
I have a distinct memory of being on a busy city street, probably waiting for my mother outside some office, and looking at the people walking by and thinking, “Almost all of these people have at least a quarter in their pockets, and it means next to nothing to them, but it would be massive wealth to me. It would be food today to me.”
Have you had that moment, too? I’m sure we all must, at some point, be in the position where we see something that would be so simple to be given, yet is withheld.
My mom would beg. Not in the strangers-on-the-street way — she took us on rounds of specific people: relatives, social workers, the volunteers at the local AA, churches.
My older sister, once she reached majority, did the same. I was one of her very frequent targets, starting while I was still in high school, “lending” her my babysitting money “for gas” until my twin sister pointed out, “You’ve leant her almost $50 five dollars at a time, and you’ll never see any of it back.”
(When she was asked for five bucks for gas, twelve-year-old Grace made Terrisa sign a repayment document promising ten percent interest compacted daily, and then Grace made a habit of alerting Terri to her current balance until it was over $1,000. I learned a valuable lesson about interest rates. Terrisa stopped asking Grace for five dollars for gas. I digress.)
My dad was too proud, and taught me to be the same, to believe it was better to starve in dignity. Never ask, always give. If you have ten cents free at the end of the month, you give it to charity. If you’re flat broke at the end of the month, you stay in and wait for work to start again.
The thing is, that dignity is something so ingrained, so socially demanded, that it makes it hard to break the habit and ask for something, even in situations where it is not taboo. I can’t bear to ask a waitress to take back food I can’t eat because of a dietary restriction, for example. My friends have caught me sitting miserably in front of an untouched plate many times and flagged down the waiter.
Have you ever had to beg?
I was thinking about this recently, about the war we have against the needy, about how ashamed we are, how we want them to go away, but we don’t want to give them a dollar. Cities treat the homeless as a problem to be gotten rid of, not citizens to help. As if the problem weren’t poverty, but having to be aware of it.
When I was a kid, I went hungry surrounded by people who had enough to eat.
The sense of grievance is real, and yet, now I am comfortable, I can see it from the other side, the sense of “but that’s not my fault!” and “They’ll only spend it on booze!” Every panhandler comes forward with a story, one crafted to be deserving. Their child is sick, they just need bus fare, they are clean and sober and always, always religious… I want to cry, “Just tell me the truth! Let’s be humans here together, not solicitor and solicited.”
I try to keep spare change in my pocket, in case I meet someone who needs it. I feel horrible when I don’t have anything. It takes forethought. I run out. Should I treat every excursion into the public streets as a trip to the strip club and stock up on ones?
Eew. That very image. Still, I feel this weird desire to point out that giving to the needy should be done, yes, directly. Respect their adulthood. They get as much choice how they spend their money as you do. Are they going to spend it on booze? Wouldn’t you? Doesn’t someone in misery deserve the only pleasure obtainable to them?
More than that, I try to engage the panhandler, talk to them. Find out something. It’s hard. They don’t want to veer from their script. They know they have much more to lose from our conversation than I do. After all, that dollar in my pocket is just spare change. I won’t even notice its absence.