I wrote previously about obsessions, about how chasing your weird is okay, good even. The self-editing we do to avoid our kinks and favorite tropes can create bland, uninteresting prose.

But… there is a point when it’s a problem.

It took me some thought to sort out the line at which an author’s obsessions got in the way of my enjoyment of their fiction. It’s when the story serves the obsession more than the obsession serves the story.

The obsession must serve the story, not the other way around.

I read this one three-book series, I’ll withhold the title and author for kindness’ sake. The author clearly loved torture, and kept having their main character end up tortured. Then, at the end of the third book, despite having set up multiple potential ways the main character could escape at the end, the main character just… dies from the torture. This made the whole series have no point? Nothing the character did made any difference, nothing mattered, nothing changed. For three books! Why set up various ways to have the happy ending and then drop it?

In the afterward, they said that they struggled to find their ending and that some readers felt that a happy ending would be “unrealistic.” Ookay but also… now I feel like I wasted time reading these books when I could have just read the first half of the first one and gotten all the story?

I think this writer just could not bring themselves to end the torture. And, hey, there is an audience for that. I am somewhat the audience for that. I like reading about severe power imbalances and high emotional stakes, but I can’t stand a story without some form of structure. If the end message is that the bad guys cannot be defeated, I need to feel that this message changes something, either in my perception of the world, or the story itself.

If you are in a similar situation, take a moment and ask: what is the point of this story? What do I want the take-away message to be? Stories have shape, they have structures, so that they properly deliver an emotional payload. (Maybe check out this post I wrote about crafting endings.)

It is always harder to get characters out of trouble than into it, but that’s a reason for weak endings, not an excuse. Every author has a free, multi-use time machine they can use to plant the means of escape earlier in the story. If they want to.

Author, Accuse Thyself

When I write about problems in writing, I know I have to look to myself, and my own mistakes, as much as (or optimally more than) I throw stones at others. When have my own obsessions stood in my way?

In Mot the Stupid, I kept being distracted by the power imbalances. Indeed, I kept having my character get re-captured, just like that other unnamed writer. I had to recognize I was doing it and stop. The point of the story is Mot’s resourcefulness, his ability to rise above his society’s expectations for him, down to giving him the moniker “stupid” just because he questions how things are done. Therefore, the story has to show Mot slowly coming into power, into strength, and that means he has to escape capture and stay free, no matter how difficult it is to plot out that escape, nor the delightful sarcastic quips that I don’t get to use if he’s not in a position to talk to his oppressors. (Well, don’t get to use AS MUCH.)

We have to be prepared to sacrifice many things in pursuit of a story that is complete and satisfying. That ABOUT has to come before the fun phrase, the witty dialog, the cool action sequence. If you are telling a straight-up action adventure, well, one of the things your story is about is defeating the bad guys and succeeding, whatever that success means. It isn’t “unrealistic” to have a happy ending. It’s unrealistic to have a happy ending that is un-earned, and the work of plot is to plant that earning in place.

How to fix it?

I think we all have The Thing we can’t help putting in our stories. Jeff Vandermeer is going to have some weird plant. Steven King is going to have drunks and daddy issues. We gotta write what we gotta write, but we have to balance it with having a story worth reading, and that means a story with a satisfying conclusion.

What makes a satisfying conclusion? An ending that has something to do with what the story is, at its heart, about. So ask yourself, What am I trying to say? What is the ineffable thing I’m trying to make effable in this? There you will find your answer.

With a quiet mind, think back to the moment you decided to write this. What excited you about the project, what emotion did you want to elicit?

One method I teach is called MICE:

MileuThe setting is most important, end when you leave the setting
IdeaAn idea is most important, end when you answer the question
CharacterCharacter is most important, end when you change the character or character refuses to change (tragedy)
EventAction is most important, end when you resolve the inciting event – the baddies are defeated, the explosion is over, the virus is cured, etc.

If your story is about exploring character, the story will feel incomplete if it doesn’t reveal a new layer or a change to that character. If it’s about defeating the bad guy, you kinda have to defeat the bad guy. If it’s about understanding what makes a guy bad, you have to show us the answer to that question. Or at least one answer.

When in doubt, look at your opening. That’s where you made your promise to the reader, where you set down what sort of story this is going to be. Openings make promises, endings keep them, or subvert them in an interesting and intentional way.

Hope this helps.

Categories: Blathering